This is my speculation as I posted it on GameFAQs. This information is also posted on some other forums in some form. The speculation is ordered by date of post and, should you read it all, you will notice changes in things as I researched.
August 1, 2009OK, let’s start off with the original airing:
--------
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (2006)1 - The Adventures of Mikuru Asahina Episode 00
2 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part I
3- The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part II
4 - The Boredom of Haruhi Suzumiya
5 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part III
6 - Remote Island Syndrome Part I
7 - Mystérique Sign
8 - Remote Island Syndrome Part II
9 - Someday in the Rain
10 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part IV
11 - The Day of Sagittarius
12 - Live Alive
13 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part V
14 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part VI
--------
Obviously this was done to extend the main story that was featured, plus it’s interesting mixed-up order caused a lot of buzz and helped the series gain interest. This is the order in which I see most people say to watch the series for the first time
“It’s the way it was meant to be watched.”
OK, well, that’s good when just watching the original series. But what about any future seasons? Will they be broadcast in mixed-up orders as well? No. KyoAni/Kadokawa had no intention to. Why? Well, let’s look at the DVD releases:
--------
Japanese DVD Volumes00 - Episode 00
1 - Melancholy 1-2
2 - Melancholy 3-4
3 - Melancholy 5-6
4 - Boredom and Mysterique Sign
5 - Remote 1-2
6 - Live and Sagittarius
7 - Someday in the Rain
--------
With the exception of 00, the volumes have the episodes in chronological order. Why change it from the broadcast order? Well, in all likelihood they intended to make the series a chronological one in the future.
However, how would they go about going in chronological order? They missed 3 stories that take place during the timeline of the first season. Also, there were rumors that the original season was meant to include more episodes but for whatever reason that wasn’t the case. Were those three stories going to be the extra episodes? We may never know, but at any rate KyoAni/Kadokawa knew that the next season would feature Vanishment and have been promoting it that way. However, what to do with those stories left unanimated? I know I questioned Episode 00 and wondered what all happened in that movie. Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody is important to the Vanishment Story. And Endless Eight, well, it’s just quirky.
At any rate, we have a problem. The original 2006 airing has it’s own timeline and many still watch the DVDs by playing that episode order. So if a new season starts up in chronological order, with BLR and stuff happening first, how does the viewer who’s only seen the broadcast order determine what’s going on? So, how does one correct the original airing and finish up the stories that take place before Vanishment in order to get everyone on the same page?
You retcon the first season and air TMoHS (2009):
--------
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (2009)1 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part I
2 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part II
3 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part III
4 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part IV
5 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part V
6 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part VI
7 - The Boredom of Haruhi Suzumiya
8 - Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody
9 - Mystérique Sign
10 - Remote Island Syndrome Part I
11 - Remote Island Syndrome Part II
12 - Endless Eight
13 - Endless Eight
14 - Endless Eight
15 - Endless Eight
16 - Endless Eight
17 - Endless Eight
18 - Endless Eight
19 - Endless Eight*
20 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part I*
21 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part II*
22 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part III*
23 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part IV*
24 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part V*
25 - The Adventures of Mikuru Asahina Episode 00*
26 - Live Alive*
27 - The Day of Sagittarius*
28 - Someday in the Rain*
* indicates speculated episodes that are currently unaired
--------
The original airing is now just that, and this is the new, official The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. Now there is only one official way to watch the series with an accurate timeline and the groundwork is laid to prepare for Vanishment and the rest of season 2.
I will say that there’s not 100% proof that this is how the season will go. But with the announcement of the second new DVD, the rumored volume numbering is all but confirmed. Let’s take a look at how the DVDs will be:
--------
Speculated Japanese DVD Volumes4.X - Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody
5.142857 - Endless Eight, Endless Eight
5.285714 - Endless Eight, Endless Eight
5.428571 - Endless Eight, Endless Eight
5.571428 - Endless Eight, Endless Eight
5.714285 - Sigh I, Sigh II
5.857142 - Sigh III, Sigh IV
5.999999 - Sigh V
--------
Volume 4 (or 4.X) contains BLR, which takes place in between Boredom and Mysterique Sign of the original Volume 4, thus the labeling. The second DVD is confirmed to be 5.142857 (or 5. [1/7]). This pretty much confirms the last 6 DVDs will the 5.[2/7], etc, leading up to 5.999999 (because 7/7 is obviously 1). This means those DVDs take place between Volumes 5 and 6. So the sole episode that is one 5.999999 is the episode that takes place right before Live Alive. Those who have read the Sigh novel know that the end of Sigh takes place mere hours before the events of Live Alive. Due to this numbering scheme, there is no future opportunity to place a DVD inbetween 5.999999 and 6. There is no mathematical number possible. Thus, the last episode of Sigh would have to be on that DVD. Of course, they could choose not to animate Sigh, but I did like the story because it does answer a lot of questions and it contains a few fairly important scenes. Also, there won’t be a ‘Disappearance Teaser.’ That would have to take place after Volume 7 (and likely be titled Volume 8), so unless 5.999999 doesn’t happen (unlikely, as the rumored list is right so far) then there won’t be any post-Someday in the Rain episodes in this airing.
One last thing: Why eight episodes of Endless Eight? Well, we know it was in discussion for some time with two different viewpoints. In all likelihood it was decided that they didn’t want (or couldn’t because the author didn’t want any ‘new’ filler) to create any ‘new’ content to fill up two seasons worth of episodes and so Endless Eight was the perfect story to fill out those slots. If Endless Eight would’ve only had 1 episode, then the season would have been only 21 episodes in length (give or take). Maybe the television stations wanted a full schedule, maybe Kadokawa/KyoAni thought it would still sell, who knows. At any rate, BLR deals with 3 years, and it was the first new episode in 3 years. Endless Eight has 8 episodes, and Sigh takes place once everyone is sighing in relief at the end of Endless Eight. Look at all that symbolism!
August 3, 2009This post is brought to you unofficially by ANN:
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2007-07-05/second-haruhi-season-to-be-announcedhttp://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2007-12-17/new-haruhi-suzumiya-anime-series-details-revealedhttp://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2009-02-03/haruhi-suzumiya-tv-anime-reportedly-to-relaunch-in-aprilhttp://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2009-04-03/gigazine-and-j-cast/2009-haruhi-will-be-28-episodes-longhttp://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2009-04-02/2009-haruhi-tv-run-begins-with-melancholy-i-episodehttp://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2009-05-17/2009-haruhi-tv-run-8th-episode-listed-as-new-episodehttp://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2009-05-21/new-haruhi-suzumiya-anime-episode-airs--------
It’s good to see how far we’ve come…
Anyway, I decided to brush up on my July 2008 Newtype information because that’s the one that showcases Vanishment (Disappearance if you prefer) and the 'new project.' I would post a link to a blog, but I’m not sure if I can, so instead I’ll say a few things.
First, KyoAni and Kadokawa obviously are marketing Vanishment and the new project (mentioned later). That issue was the last major time I know of.
Second, the blogger notes that they avoid ‘season 2’ in the article, instead focusing on ‘new animation’ and a saying that it “isn’t merely a second season,” as the blog says. The promotional stuff that referenced BLR and Tanabata is also in that article.
Third, let’s go further back in time to the original site teasing Vanishment. It said season 2, announced earlier that year, was cancelled and that a ‘new project’ was being made. This indicates that even in 2007 they were probably planning this relaunch of the franchise.
Basically, it matches up with that one guy (what’s his name) saying this has been in the works for awhile (although that just mentioned Endless Eight). They’ve been discussing how exactly to do it, and yes, some of that discussion was how to do Endless Eight and, while Endless Eight currently isn’t a fan favorite right now, who knows what people will say a year or so from now. I believe Kadokawa and KyoAni are definitely planning something once this renewed airing of TMoHS finishes up, something that will definitely bring Vanishment to anime life.
One more thing, about that December 2007 teaser site and the dates on the teaser image:

2007 - Announce second season. Cancel second season. Announce new project.
2008 - Run a feature in Newtype promoting the new project.
2009 - Air the new project which turns out to be a relaunch of the series.
Vanishment for December 2009?
~~~
I want to point out that if they have been planning this relaunch since 2007, and they have been promoting Vanishment for it, and if the dates represent those things, AND if they plan to have Haruhi 2009 have the episodes I listed, then that means they would have to at least announce a season starting with Vanishment this year because this is the last date of the 'new project' and probably air it this year. Either start it right after this season or the speculated 'Friday, December 18.' You can't promote one story arc for a something and not use it when the time comes. I think they have every intention of airing it.
~~~
(Amazon DVD reveal)
http://www.amazon.co.jp/exec/obidos/ASIN/B002JPC9CG/Lists that version of 5.14... (the first Endless Eight DVD) will come with a box that is able to contain 4 DVDs. All of your Endless Eight DVDs will now fit in one, convenient box! Also, the next Newtype is rumored to feature an Endless Eight article, I think. Basically, more evidence that Endless Eight will indeed end next episode.
~~~
OK, let’s talk about copyright. Now, I’m not that knowledgable about copyright but I know a few things. If anything I’m about to say is not correct, please feel free to clarify.
I want to start by saying what I think is the case. When filing for a copyright, you can file for a copyright of a collection of works that will be listed under one name/title. All works filed under that name/title will feature the same copyright.
I should note that magazine images have been cropped to for size and to focus more on copyright dates.
Let’s start with the promotion pic used in Newtype in mid-2007:

As you can see, this picture only has a copyright for 2007. Now, whether this is because it’s simply being used to promote an upcoming Newtype feature or event or if, at the time, season 2 was indeed in planning…I don’t know. All I believe is that this was filed under a single copyright not related to what’s coming up next and, for the sake of speculation, I’ll assume it’s because it’s related to a Newtype promotion.
Also, note the page itself does reference BLR (you can't see in this cropped version. Also, the viral video appeared shortly thereafter iirc).
Once again, the December 2007 teaser pic:

I noted before how this picture is copyrighted for 2007, 2008, 2009. I think it has to do with this being part of some sort of collection of works, with this probably being the first work publicly displayed. This could mean that the original season 2, now canceled, was either planned to ‘vanish’ from the start or that somewhere between July 2007 and December 2007 Kadokawa and KyoAni decided to change their plans. I’m thinking the former would be more probable in the grand scheme of things. Of course, if the first image is indeed copyrighted to the second season instead of a Newtype promotion, then the latter would probably be the case.
This would be the part where I show something from the July 2008 Newtype, but unfortunately I couldn’t find anything large enough to make out anything. Feel free to add your own, as I suspect that those images would be copyrighted 2007, 2008, 2009 as well.
The early 2009 Newtype ran a feature about the finally announced relaunch of the franchise, complete with Yuki on the cover. On page 12, the cover image is shown with legal information (I assume):

Once again, it is copyrighted 2007, 2008, 2009. It is directly related to the new project, now confirmed to be a relaunch of the series.
Next up (no image though) is the first episode of The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (2009), Melancholy I. This episode, when it originally aired, featured a 2006 copyright. I assume the whole series was copyrighted under a single name/title. Now, when that episode re-aired there was some changes in the credits (I’m pretty sure) but the copyright is still 2006. This is because all they did was use a work they originally copyrighted. As the copyright owner, Kadokawa can use their materials however they want. In this case, they decided to use the original 14 episodes from The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya for another project. Luckily they didn’t decide to reanimate all of them because then there’s the option of re-buying the episodes. Would you rather buy 8 episodes of “the same content” or 22 episodes? Anyway, while they aren’t featured under the new copyright, they are still being used as part of the relaunch of the series and are meant to be viewed that way.
You are not supposed to differentiate between the new episodes from the old in this airing. It is all one complete season. This is what Kadokawa/KyoAni are promoting it as.Finally are the episodes that are newly animated (the long mentioned ‘new animation’ in promoting the new project). This image taken from Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody (although it’s in all newly animated episodes):

Once again, the 2007, 2008, 2009 copyright. These newly animated episodes share a copyright because they are all connected to the larger copyright (probably the relaunch as a whole, but I wonder what the actual name of the copyright these would be filed under is).
For a relaunch to be complete, you need to start at square one. In this case, the very first episode chronologically. In order to fill out a complete two seasons of air time without getting into Vanishment yet, they needed to find some way to extend the season slightly while still remaining fairly faithful to the source material. Endless Eight was the only way to do so. While the loop numbers have changed from the original, it’s not really that critical to the story as long as the loop finally ends the same way. Also, there’s that whole “symbolism” stuff I mentioned earlier in this topic. And of course money.
The key thing here, something I want to make sure is thought about, is that this is the last year of the copyright. 2007 and 2008’s works featured Vanishment heavily, the focus on the Haruhi franchise being relaunched/restarted/renewed/whatever you want to call it, and there was some BLR stuff too to start out with. It was all promoting the stuff to come. It is now 2009. The relaunch has been realized. BLR has been realized. What signs indicate Vanishment won’t be, too?
~~~
I am puzzled at how exactly they'd plan to fit Vanishment and what follows after into 2009, though, as a full season. From what I see, if it starts right after TMoHS 2009, then there'd only be 11 weeks left in the year. Of course they may just have a season 10 episodes or so, who knows. Well...if the season went into 2010, I guess the episodes would be made before then and already copyrighted for 2009, so meh (there'd only be a couple episodes in 2010 and they'd have them done long before the new year, assuming a short season).
Anyway, my mind keeps thinking about the possibility of Vanishment getting a theatrical release. That way, they keep Vanishment in 2009 and don't have to worry about anything past that yet. Plus, it could release on the often mentioned December 18, 2009.
I've seen blogs saying the promotions have said relaunch of the 'series' and also relaunch of the 'franchise,' so I'm not sure which is right or if both are. At any rate, I suppose a movie is possible...
~~~
And finally, my general thoughts on what is going to happen:
TMoHS (2006) no longer exists as far as Haruhi anime canon is concerned. And what I mean by that is the broadcast order, it's set up in a way so that you can't really continue the series without some difficulties.
So, after three years of waiting with plenty of promotional build-up, the new Haruhi franchise is born. Of course, in order to do so, you have to start right at the beginning and thus re-do the first season.
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (2009)1 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part I
2 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part II
3 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part III
4 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part IV
5 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part V
6 - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya Part VI
7 - The Boredom of Haruhi Suzumiya
8 - Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody
9 - Mystérique Sign
10 - Remote Island Syndrome Part I
11 - Remote Island Syndrome Part II
12 - Endless Eight
13 - Endless Eight
14 - Endless Eight
15 - Endless Eight
16 - Endless Eight
17 - Endless Eight
18 - Endless Eight
19 - Endless Eight
20 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part I
21 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part II
22 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part III
23 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part IV
24 - The Sigh of Haruhi Suzumiya Part V
25 - The Adventures of Mikuru Asahina Episode 00
26 - Live Alive
27 - The Day of Sagittarius
28 - Someday in the Rain
With such a heavy focus on Vanishment and knowing the otakus are dying to see it animated, what do you as a business? What would be the most profitable? What would stick within your 2007, 2008, 2009 plans to finally own up to your teasing?
'The Vanishment of Haruhi Suzumiya' theatrical release, set to air Friday, December 18, 2009, exactly three years after the original teaser image. Probably announce it after Someday in the Rain airs.
The second season, picking up after the events of the movie, will air sometime late 2010 or early 2011, probably. Haruhi 2009 DVDs won't fully be out until March 2010 or so, plus you'd want to get the movie out to retail before you start a new season. This gives KyoAni a break from Haruhi (Haruhi-chan, new TMoHS episodes, and then the movie in one year, ouch!) and time for some other stuff (like more FMP ;_;).
August 4, 2009I think Intrigues would then be able to be the main focus of the season following TMoHS 2009 and the Vanishment movie. It would start with the short post-Vanishment stories and then Intrigues (which is the longest novel up to that point, the author mentions it at the end. I just got done re-reading it not too long ago >_>). Maybe have the novel 8 stories to end it.
Also, there's the possibility that novel 10 is being held back to promote a new season, so maybe novels 9 and 10 could also be animated as the conclusion to that season.
~~~
Alright, maybe I can try to explain my thought process on this. Sorry if some of this is the same as what I’ve said earlier in the topic (or even information that is repeated in this post lol). This topic is sort of my progression through speculation, so it changes a little to fit my current mindset.
Yamamoto left KyoAni around July 2007. We now know for sure that Endless Eight was being discussed while he was still there. Also, the second season was announced 7/7/2007 (Tanabata) and appropriately reference Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody (which is the one story that needed to be animated for sure in order to animate Vanishment).
I’m confident that this shows that the new project was in planning sometime between late 2006 and up to the 7/7/07 announcement. Obviously we only know Endless Eight was a discussion, but if we know that, plus the fact that BLR is a necessary Vanishment component, we can assume they were planning out how to get all the pre-Vanishment episodes animated and out to the public (so that would include Sigh) in that time period. At this point, I think there was a decision at some point stating that they would have to fix the airing order of the original season so they could work on future projects. This would the the relaunch of the franchise starting with the renewed airing of the first season. I think Endless Eight talk was purely how long they were willing to stretch it out (keep it short or go for the ‘8’ symbolism). Plus, they could profit from extra DVD sales. The length of Endless Eight would not interfere with any of the other stories.
Because this relaunch was decided before the second season announcement, I think at this point I’m fairly confident now (after checking Yamamoto’s information regarding leaving KyoAni) that the second season announcement was meant to be canceled later on from the start. That referenced BLR. Next, the teaser site that heavily referenced Vanishment. This is when the 2007, 2008, 2009 copyright appeared. At this point in time they probably had the general guideline of what they wanted to do with the now announced ‘new project.’ So all of what has happened has been planned since then.
We know that the new project is essentially the relaunch of the franchise. The first part of that, which was planned way back in 2007, is the renewed airing of TMoHS. However, all signs are indicating that Vanishment is not being featured in this season. They obviously want to place extra focus on Vanishment by the fact that they aren’t having it be the conclusion to this season. However, if they already had this planned in 2007, then there was some reason they used Vanishment as well as BLR to promote it. I’ll repeat again that this is still reason to believe Vanishment will be animated this year. However, given the amount of time left after this season finishes up, a new season would essentially have to air right after this current one. Certainly possible, but then we would hear an announcement sometime before that from someone. I think this renewed airing was announced one month before (correct me if I’m wrong) so we’d hear something about a new season in September (most likely).
But then, what about symbolism? You promote BLR on 7/7/07 (Tanabata). You promote Vanishment on 12/18/07 (key date for the novel). You wait three years to actually start the project, which references BLR, plus it was the first new animation episode. You ultimately decide upon the 8 episodes of Endless Eight. So far, symbolism has been huge for this project. Now, December 18, 2009. It happens to be a Friday. Now, this is when the first couple stations air TMoHS 2009, so there could be a new season starting then. But that would mean most of the episodes fall into 2010, with some of them likely being animated in 2010. I would think they’d have the copyright go into 2010 if they planned that. But no, I think the fact the 18th is on a Friday was perfect for Kadokawa. It’s an exceptional opportunity to premiere a Vanishment movie exactly three years after the original teaser related to it. The movie would be the final stage of the original guideline of the new project and a would certainly be a grand way to end to finish it off.
August 6, 2009The checklist based on the speculation debuts 12 hours before the next episode:

Shortly after that, ANN reports the next Newtype will be running a feature on Endless Eight and confirms it will have concluded on episode 19 (the feature is written in past tense because the leak was an early copy).
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2009-08-05/haruhi-endless-eight-arc-confirmed-to-endAfter the airing does showcase the conclusion, the checklist is updated:
August 7, 2007Some more food for thought:
Cowboy Bebop’s first television appearance, starting April 3, 1998, was a shortened run consisting of only 12 episodes, those being what would become known as episodes 2, 3, 7-15, and 18. However, it was known then that the creators had more that they wanted to show and that Cowboy Bebop would soon air in its entirety. Later that year, on October 23, Cowboy Bebop began its re-airing with a scheduled 26 episodes. Today, the original airing of Cowboy Bebop is not considered to be the ‘first season,’ instead the 26 episode airing is what the creators had in mind for their series and is the only one that counts.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowboy_BebopBlack Lagoon’s first season consists of 12 episodes, numbered accordingly 1-12. The next airing, consisting of 12 episodes as well, are labeled 13-24. However, the second airing was given the title Black Lagoon: The Second Barrage. While the 24 episodes are labeled starting at the first episode and thus may be confused as one whole season, the two separate airings were given different names and are intended to be two separate seasons.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_LagoonThe moral of the story: The creators of something have the final say in how their works should be viewed. The original broadcast of The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya in 2006 consists of 14 episodes aired in a certain way. Three years later, the creators of the anime began airing a rebroadcast of the series, this time showing it with the episodes they wanted included in it (now totaling 28 in episode count) and the order they should be watched., effectively stating the original airing is no longer part of the series.
~~~
This is just a small bit.
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2009-02-06/staff-for-renewed-airing-of-haruhi-suzumiya-announcedI was curious as to how involved Tanigawa was in this renewed airing. I forgot about the change in staff for this season and, sure enough, he is listed as "Original Creator/Development Collaboration." Which means he knew about eight episodes of Endless Eight and could very well have been part of the discussion over it. Not sure how big his role of 'development collaboration' is, though.
August 8, 2009
Just some more speculation, probably repetitive but it's written in a different way.Here's what I think:
1. After TMoHS (2006) they were planning on how to do the second season.
2. They released the episodes in chronological order (except 00) on the DVDs because they knew they wanted to get the series into that order eventually, just didn't know how exactly at the time.
3. As the series became really popular and started making a lot of money, they knew the majority of the fans liked the Vanishment novel the best and, based on what they've animated already, knew that Vanishment would be part of the second season. However, they had three other story arcs left to animate that take place before Vanishment. If they released a new season with those stories and end with Vanishment, it wouldn't be a good transition from the broadcast order of (2006). It would be: Broadcast order, then BLR, then Endless Eight, then Sigh, then Vanishment. And even if they did a mixed up order again with those stories, the series is in a chronological mess of epic proportions.
4. Instead, they began thinking of how to get those pre-Vanishment stories out before airing Vanishment. As a season itself, those stories wouldn't be very good plus you had to explain the order of the stories. Releasing them as OVAs didn't really suit them well either, as that would be quite a few episodes to just hope to sell by saying "here, buy these." Also, it would be still be a hassle trying to get everyone to understand "these OVAs fit here in the first season and we want everyone to start watching chronological order, ok?"
5. Somewhere along the line I think they began thinking of a possibility of making a Vanishment movie. It would be a good season starter, but if they do another 14 episode-ish season the last half wouldn't be the greatest story-wise. If they did it as a movie, it would not only be a sure-fire hit and make a lot of money but they could then use Intrigue as the ending of a new season (assuming a 14-ish episode season).
6. If they are planning a movie, then they went back to looking at the pre-Vanishment episodes. I think this is when the relaunch of the franchise became a thought. If they were to start over, they could 're-do' the first season and add in the new stories. Alone they aren't that great, but as a whole they have an actual 28 episode first season with plenty of different arcs that is in chronological order and easy to follow-up on.
In conclusion, I believe their main focus is on Vanishment but in order to get there they came up with this relaunch. The renewed airing is the first part of the relaunch (since it's intended to be the new first season) but is necessary in order to get to Vanishment. So while the 'new project' is the relaunch of the franchise (or maybe it's just 'new season one plus Vanishment movie?') the driving force behind it was Vanishment. This goes along with the idea they have laid out their plans since 2007 and intend to show Vanishment this year. Also why they have been teasing it heavily. As to why wait until 2009, well there's the viral marketing and symbolism they've been able to do/could do, plus we don't know what they had signed on for in 2008 already and thus couldn't do it sooner. Also, because Vanishment is their ultimate goal, if it airs in 2009 then their goal for this project, under that 2007, 2008, 2009 copyright, will be complete and any future works will be part of their own 'project' copyright.
~~~
The following is from AnimeSuki user Daniel Lind:
Originally Posted by
Daniel Lind 
Heminga13, there are some things backing up your This Is All A Part Of One Big Plan theory which are missing from your analysis.
One is pretty major. Just this July, Kadokawa launched a spin-off romance manga, "The Disappearance of Nagato Yuki-chan", made by Puyo and practically being an alternative development of Disappearance plot (as far as I understand, since it's only the first chapter out at this moment). If it's not a plus one point to Disappearance advertisment, then what is it?
Also the second Haruhi video game for Wii, which uses a variation of Endless Eight plot, but is set on a sea cruiser. Curiously, Nagaru Tanigawa had an active part in its production. The game was out just before reairing has started.
On a related note, the ED of Haruhi-chan that aired right before the TMoHS (2009) is speculated to reference Vanishment. Could these spin-offs be well-timed releases by Kadokawa to hint towards what is to come?
~~~
The user previously mentioned also brought up the fact that Gundam 00 (which aired late 2007/early 2008) and the second season (which aired late 2008/early 2009) are both listed under a copyright dated '2007.' This obviously indicates that copyright dates don't necessarily indicate when a work is being published/aired/whatever. I should note that according the Bandai's U.S. website the Gundam 00 copyright is now 2007-2009, which I think means it was updated when they announced the movie sequel. I'm not sure at this time, however.
I still believe that the fact the Haruhi copyright is 2007, 2008, 2009 (with it being that way since it first appeared) is suspicious. It could mean any number of things (or nothing at all) but I think it might have been a subtle hint to the fans of the series. I also still believe that we'll see Vanishment by the end of the year but, as copyright dates aren't concrete evidence as to when a work appears, it is not necessarily going to happen.
~~~
I also want to point out the excerpt from an interview taken from the Sept. 2009 Newtype (pretty sure it's from that) which Sankaku Complex posted.
“There are a lot of episodes from the novels which have not been animated. We’d love to hear which of those you would like to make into a movie.”
Ishihara: “Endless Eight… :-) Can’t we do that again, adding some new extras, try some film tricks out? Or is it too much? :-)”
I am curious that this was brought up, as this may very well be the last big Haruhi feature in Newtype until the announcement of the next project in the franchise. Also, the interviewer asked for a story from the novels (actually, 'episodes from the novels' but basically the same thing) that isn't yet animated, but Ishihara said 'Endless Eight' to both avoid answering the question truthfully and also answering jokingly in the process. [No, it was not a serious reply. Anyone who says it is didn't really read it.]
Part II here:
http://heminga13.livejournal.com/1298.htmlFor the original topic:
http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/genmessage.php?board=2000121&topic=50720096